FIRST SEARCHES FOR OPTICAL COUNTERPARTS TO GRAVITATIONAL-WAVE CANDIDATE EVENTS

Academic Article

Abstract

  • During the LIGO and Virgo joint science runs in 2009-2010, gravitational wave (GW) data from three interferometer detectors were analyzed within minutes to select GW candidate events and infer their apparent sky positions. Target coordinates were transmitted to several telescopes for follow-up observations aimed at the detection of an associated optical transient. Images were obtained for eight such GW candidates. We present the methods used to analyze the image data as well as the transient search results. No optical transient was identified with a convincing association with any of these candidates, and none of the GW triggers showed strong evidence for being astrophysical in nature. We compare the sensitivities of these observations to several model light curves from possible sources of interest, and discuss prospects for future joint GW-optical observations of this type.
  • Authors

  • Aasi, J
  • Abadie, J
  • Abbott, BP
  • Abbott, R
  • Abbott, T
  • Abernathy, MR
  • Accadia, T
  • Acernese, F
  • Adams, C
  • Adams, T
  • Adhikari, RX
  • Affeldt, C
  • Agathos, M
  • Aggarwal, N
  • Aguiar, OD
  • Ajith, P
  • Allen, B
  • Allocca, A
  • Ceron, E Amador
  • Amariutei, D
  • Anderson, RA
  • Anderson, SB
  • Anderson, WG
  • Arai, K
  • Araya, MC
  • Arceneaux, C
  • Areeda, J
  • Ast, S
  • Aston, SM
  • Astone, P
  • Aufmuth, P
  • Aulbert, C
  • Austin, L
  • Aylott, BE
  • Babak, S
  • Baker, PT
  • Ballardin, G
  • Ballmer, SW
  • Barayoga, JC
  • Barker, D
  • Barnum, SH
  • Barone, F
  • Barr, B
  • Barsotti, L
  • Barsuglia, M
  • Barton, MA
  • Bartos, I
  • Bassiri, R
  • Basti, A
  • Batch, J
  • Bauchrowitz, J
  • Bauer, Th S
  • Bebronne, M
  • Behnke, B
  • Bejger, M
  • Beker, MG
  • Bell, AS
  • Bell, C
  • Belopolski, I
  • Bergmann, G
  • Berliner, JM
  • Bertolini, A
  • Bessis, D
  • Betzwieser, J
  • Beyersdorf, PT
  • Bhadbhade, T
  • Bilenko, IA
  • Billingsley, G
  • Birch, J
  • Bitossi, M
  • Bizouard, MA
  • Black, E
  • Blackburn, JK
  • Blackburn, L
  • Blair, D
  • Blom, M
  • Bock, O
  • Bodiya, TP
  • Boer, M
  • Bogan, C
  • Bond, C
  • Bondu, F
  • Bonelli, L
  • Bonnand, R
  • Bork, R
  • Born, M
  • Bose, S
  • Bosi, L
  • Bowers, J
  • Bradaschia, C
  • Brady, PR
  • Braginsky, VB
  • Branchesi, M
  • Brannen, CA
  • Brau, JE
  • Breyer, J
  • Briant, T
  • Bridges, DO
  • Brillet, A
  • Brinkmann, M
  • Brisson, V
  • Britzger, M
  • Brooks, AF
  • Brown, DA
  • Brown, DD
  • Brueckner, F
  • Bulik, T
  • Bulten, HJ
  • Buonanno, A
  • Buskulic, D
  • Buy, C
  • Byer, RL
  • Cadonati, L
  • Cagnoli, G
  • Calderon Bustillo, J
  • Calloni, E
  • Camp, JB
  • Campsie, P
  • Cannon, KC
  • Canuel, B
  • Cao, J
  • Capano, CD
  • Carbognani, F
  • Carbone, L
  • Caride, S
  • Castiglia, A
  • Caudill, S
  • Cavaglia, M
  • Cavalier, F
  • Cavalieri, R
  • Cella, G
  • Cepeda, C
  • Cesarini, E
  • Chakraborty, R
  • Chalermsongsak, T
  • Chao, S
  • Charlton, P
  • Chassande-Mottin, E
  • Chen, X
  • Chen, Y
  • Chincarini, A
  • Chiummo, A
  • Cho, HS
  • Chow, J
  • Christensen, N
  • Chu, Q
  • Chua, SSY
  • Chung, S
  • Ciani, G
  • Clara, F
  • Clark, DE
  • Clark, JA
  • Cleva, F
  • Coccia, E
  • Cohadon, P-F
  • Colla, A
  • Colombini, M
  • Jr, Constancio M
  • Conte, A
  • Conte, R
  • Cook, D
  • Corbitt, TR
  • Cordier, M
  • Cornish, N
  • Corsi, A
  • Costa, CA
  • Coughlin, MW
  • Coulon, J-P
  • Countryman, S
  • Couvares, P
  • Coward, DM
  • Cowart, M
  • Coyne, DC
  • Craig, K
  • Creighton, JDE
  • Creighton, TD
  • Crowder, SG
  • Cumming, A
  • Cunningham, L
  • Cuoco, E
  • Dahl, K
  • Dal Canton, T
  • Damjanic, M
  • Danilishin, SL
  • D'Antonio, S
  • Danzmann, K
  • Dattilo, V
  • Daudert, B
  • Daveloza, H
  • Davier, M
  • Davies, GS
  • Daw, EJ
  • Day, R
  • Dayanga, T
  • De Rosa, R
  • Debreczeni, G
  • Degallaix, J
  • Del Pozzo, W
  • Deleeuw, E
  • Deleglise, S
  • Denker, T
  • Dereli, H
  • Dergachev, V
  • DeRosa, R
  • DeSalvo, R
  • Dhurandhar, S
  • Di Fiore, L
  • Di Lieto, A
  • Di Palma, I
  • Di Virgilio, A
  • Diaz, M
  • Dietz, A
  • Dmitry, K
  • Donovan, F
  • Dooley, KL
  • Doravari, S
  • Drago, M
  • Drever, RWP
  • Driggers, JC
  • Du, Z
  • Dumas, J-C
  • Dwyer, S
  • Eberle, T
  • Edwards, M
  • Effler, A
  • Ehrens, P
  • Eichholz, J
  • Eikenberry, SS
  • Endroczi, G
  • Essick, R
  • Etzel, T
  • Evans, K
  • Evans, M
  • Evans, T
  • Factourovich, M
  • Fafone, V
  • Fairhurst, S
  • Fang, Q
  • Farr, B
  • Farr, W
  • Favata, M
  • Fazi, D
  • Fehrmann, H
  • Feldbaum, D
  • Ferrante, I
  • Ferrini, F
  • Fidecaro, F
  • Finn, LS
  • Fiori, I
  • Fisher, R
  • Flaminio, R
  • Foley, E
  • Foley, S
  • Forsi, E
  • Forte, LA
  • Fotopoulos, N
  • Fournier, J-D
  • Franco, S
  • Frasca, S
  • Frasconi, F
  • Frede, M
  • Frei, M
  • Frei, Z
  • Freise, A
  • Frey, R
  • Fricke, TT
  • Fritschel, P
  • Frolov, VV
  • Fujimoto, M-K
  • Fulda, P
  • Fyffe, M
  • Gair, J
  • Gammaitoni, L
  • Garcia, J
  • Garufi, F
  • Gehrels, N
  • Gemme, G
  • Genin, E
  • Gennai, A
  • Gergely, L
  • Ghosh, S
  • Giaime, JA
  • Giampanis, S
  • Giardina, KD
  • Giazotto, A
  • Gil-Casanova, S
  • Gill, C
  • Gleason, J
  • Goetz, E
  • Goetz, R
  • Gondan, L
  • Gonzalez, G
  • Gordon, N
  • Gorodetsky, ML
  • Gossan, S
  • Gossler, S
  • Gouaty, R
  • Graef, C
  • Graff, PB
  • Granata, M
  • Grant, A
  • Gras, S
  • Gray, C
  • Greenhalgh, RJS
  • Gretarsson, AM
  • Griffo, C
  • Grote, H
  • Grover, K
  • Grunewald, S
  • Guidi, GM
  • Guido, C
  • Gushwa, KE
  • Gustafson, EK
  • Gustafson, R
  • Hall, B
  • Hall, E
  • Hammer, D
  • Hammond, G
  • Hanke, M
  • Hanks, J
  • Hanna, C
  • Hanson, J
  • Harms, J
  • Harry, GM
  • Harry, IW
  • Harstad, ED
  • Hartman, MT
  • Haughian, K
  • Hayama, K
  • Heefner, J
  • Heidmann, A
  • Heintze, M
  • Heitmann, H
  • Hello, P
  • Hemming, G
  • Hendry, M
  • Heng, IS
  • Heptonstall, AW
  • Heurs, M
  • Hild, S
  • Hoak, D
  • Hodge, KA
  • Holt, K
  • Holtrop, Maurik
  • Hong, T
  • Hooper, S
  • Horrom, T
  • Hosken, DJ
  • Hough, J
  • Howell, EJ
  • Hu, Y
  • Hua, Z
  • Huang, V
  • Huerta, EA
  • Hughey, B
  • Husa, S
  • Huttner, SH
  • Huynh, M
  • Huynh-Dinh, T
  • Iafrate, J
  • Ingram, DR
  • Inta, R
  • Isogai, T
  • Ivanov, A
  • Iyer, BR
  • Izumi, K
  • Jacobson, M
  • James, E
  • Jang, H
  • Jang, YJ
  • Jaranowski, P
  • Jimenez-Forteza, F
  • Johnson, WW
  • Jones, D
  • Jones, DI
  • Jones, R
  • Jonker, RJG
  • Ju, L
  • Haris, K
  • Kalmus, P
  • Kalogera, V
  • Kandhasamy, S
  • Kang, G
  • Kanner, JB
  • Kasprzack, M
  • Kasturi, R
  • Katsavounidis, E
  • Katzman, W
  • Kaufer, H
  • Kaufman, K
  • Kawabe, K
  • Kawamura, S
  • Kawazoe, F
  • Kefelian, F
  • Keitel, D
  • Kelley, DB
  • Kells, W
  • Keppel, DG
  • Khalaidovski, A
  • Khalili, FY
  • Khazanov, EA
  • Kim, BK
  • Kim, C
  • Kim, K
  • Kim, N
  • Kim, W
  • Kim, Y-M
  • King, EJ
  • King, PJ
  • Kinzel, DL
  • Kissel, JS
  • Klimenko, S
  • Kline, J
  • Koehlenbeck, S
  • Kokeyama, K
  • Kondrashov, V
  • Koranda, S
  • Korth, WZ
  • Kowalska, I
  • Kozak, D
  • Kremin, A
  • Kringel, V
  • Krishnan, B
  • Krolak, A
  • Kucharczyk, C
  • Kudla, S
  • Kuehn, G
  • Kumar, A
  • Kumar, P
  • Kumar, R
  • Kurdyumov, R
  • Kwee, P
  • Landry, M
  • Lantz, B
  • Larson, S
  • Lasky, PD
  • Lawrie, C
  • Lazzarini, A
  • Le Roux, A
  • Leaci, P
  • Lebigot, EO
  • Lee, C-H
  • Lee, HK
  • Lee, HM
  • Lee, J
  • Lee, J
  • Leonardi, M
  • Leong, JR
  • Leroy, N
  • Letendre, N
  • Levine, B
  • Lewis, JB
  • Lhuillier, V
  • Li, TGF
  • Lin, AC
  • Littenberg, TB
  • Litvine, V
  • Liu, F
  • Liu, H
  • Liu, Y
  • Liu, Z
  • Lloyd, D
  • Lockerbie, NA
  • Lockett, V
  • Lodhia, D
  • Loew, K
  • Logue, J
  • Lombardi, AL
  • Lorenzini, M
  • Loriette, V
  • Lormand, M
  • Losurdo, G
  • Lough, J
  • Luan, J
  • Lubinski, MJ
  • Lueck, H
  • Lundgren, AP
  • Macarthur, J
  • Macdonald, E
  • Machenschalk, B
  • MacInnis, M
  • Macleod, DM
  • Magana-Sandoval, F
  • Mageswaran, M
  • Mailand, K
  • Majorana, E
  • Maksimovic, I
  • Malvezzi, V
  • Man, N
  • Manca, GM
  • Mandel, I
  • Mandic, V
  • Mangano, V
  • Mantovani, M
  • Marchesoni, F
  • Marion, F
  • Marka, S
  • Marka, Z
  • Markosyan, A
  • Maros, E
  • Marque, J
  • Martelli, F
  • Martin, IW
  • Martin, RM
  • Martinelli, L
  • Martynov, D
  • Marx, JN
  • Mason, K
  • Masserot, A
  • Massinger, TJ
  • Matichard, F
  • Matone, L
  • Matzner, RA
  • Mavalvala, N
  • May, G
  • Mazumder, N
  • Mazzolo, G
  • McCarthy, R
  • McClelland, DE
  • McGuire, SC
  • McIntyre, G
  • McIver, J
  • Meacher, D
  • Meadors, GD
  • Mehmet, M
  • Meidam, J
  • Meier, T
  • Melatos, A
  • Mendell, G
  • Mercer, RA
  • Meshkov, S
  • Messenger, C
  • Meyer, MS
  • Miao, H
  • Michel, C
  • Mikhailov, EE
  • Milano, L
  • Miller, J
  • Minenkov, Y
  • Mingarelli, CMF
  • Mitra, S
  • Mitrofanov, VP
  • Mitselmakher, G
  • Mittleman, R
  • Moe, B
  • Mohan, M
  • Mohapatra, SRP
  • Mokler, F
  • Moraru, D
  • Moreno, G
  • Morgado, N
  • Mori, T
  • Morriss, SR
  • Mossavi, K
  • Mours, B
  • Mow-Lowry, CM
  • Mueller, CL
  • Mueller, G
  • Mukherjee, S
  • Mullavey, A
  • Munch, J
  • Murphy, D
  • Murray, PG
  • Mytidis, A
  • Nagy, MF
  • Kumar, D Nanda
  • Nardecchia, I
  • Nash, T
  • Naticchioni, L
  • Nayak, R
  • Necula, V
  • Neri, I
  • Newton, G
  • Nguyen, T
  • Nishida, E
  • Nishizawa, A
  • Nitz, A
  • Nocera, F
  • Nolting, D
  • Normandin, ME
  • Nuttall, LK
  • Ochsner, E
  • O'Dell, J
  • Oelker, E
  • Ogin, GH
  • Oh, JJ
  • Oh, SH
  • Ohme, F
  • Oppermann, P
  • O'Reilly, B
  • Larcher, W Ortega
  • O'Shaughnessy, R
  • Osthelder, C
  • Ottaway, DJ
  • Ottens, RS
  • Ou, J
  • Overmier, H
  • Owen, BJ
  • Padilla, C
  • Pai, A
  • Palomba, C
  • Pan, Y
  • Pankow, C
  • Paoletti, F
  • Paoletti, R
  • Papa, MA
  • Paris, H
  • Pasqualetti, A
  • Passaquieti, R
  • Passuello, D
  • Pedraza, M
  • Peiris, P
  • Penn, S
  • Perreca, A
  • Phelps, M
  • Pichot, M
  • Pickenpack, M
  • Piergiovanni, F
  • Pierro, V
  • Pinard, L
  • Pindor, B
  • Pinto, IM
  • Pitkin, M
  • Poeld, J
  • Poggiani, R
  • Poole, V
  • Poux, C
  • Predoi, V
  • Prestegard, T
  • Price, LR
  • Prijatelj, M
  • Principe, M
  • Privitera, S
  • Prix, R
  • Prodi, GA
  • Prokhorov, L
  • Puncken, O
  • Punturo, M
  • Puppo, P
  • Quetschke, V
  • Quintero, E
  • Quitzow-James, R
  • Raab, FJ
  • Rabeling, DS
  • Racz, I
  • Radkins, H
  • Raffai, P
  • Raja, S
  • Rajalakshmi, G
  • Rakhmanov, M
  • Ramet, C
  • Rapagnani, P
  • Raymond, V
  • Re, V
  • Reed, CM
  • Reed, T
  • Regimbau, T
  • Reid, S
  • Reitze, DH
  • Ricci, F
  • Riesen, R
  • Riles, K
  • Robertson, NA
  • Robinet, F
  • Rocchi, A
  • Roddy, S
  • Rodriguez, C
  • Rodruck, M
  • Roever, C
  • Rolland, L
  • Rollins, JG
  • Romano, JD
  • Romano, R
  • Romanov, G
  • Romie, JH
  • Rosinska, D
  • Rowan, S
  • Ruediger, A
  • Ruggi, P
  • Ryan, K
  • Salemi, F
  • Sammut, L
  • Sandberg, V
  • Sanders, J
  • Sannibale, V
  • Santiago-Prieto, I
  • Saracco, E
  • Sassolas, B
  • Sathyaprakash, BS
  • Saulson, PR
  • Savage, R
  • Schilling, R
  • Schnabel, R
  • Schofield, RMS
  • Schreiber, E
  • Schuette, D
  • Schulz, B
  • Schutz, BF
  • Schwinberg, P
  • Scott, J
  • Scott, SM
  • Seifert, F
  • Sellers, D
  • Sengupta, AS
  • Sentenac, D
  • Sergeev, A
  • Shaddock, D
  • Shah, S
  • Shahriar, MS
  • Shaltev, M
  • Shapiro, B
  • Shawhan, P
  • Shoemaker, DH
  • Sidery, TL
  • Siellez, K
  • Siemens, X
  • Sigg, D
  • Simakov, D
  • Singer, A
  • Singer, L
  • Sintes, AM
  • Skelton, GR
  • Slagmolen, BJJ
  • Slutsky, J
  • Smith, JR
  • Smith, MR
  • Smith, RJE
  • Smith-Lefebvre, ND
  • Soden, K
  • Son, EJ
  • Sorazu, B
  • Souradeep, T
  • Sperandio, L
  • Staley, A
  • Steinert, E
  • Steinlechner, J
  • Steinlechner, S
  • Steplewski, S
  • Stevens, D
  • Stochino, A
  • Stone, R
  • Strain, KA
  • Strigin, S
  • Stroeer, AS
  • Sturani, R
  • Stuver, AL
  • Summerscales, TZ
  • Susmithan, S
  • Sutton, PJ
  • Swinkels, B
  • Szeifert, G
  • Tacca, M
  • Talukder, D
  • Tang, L
  • Tanner, DB
  • Tarabrin, SP
  • Taylor, R
  • ter Braack, APM
  • Thirugnanasambandam, MP
  • Thomas, M
  • Thomas, P
  • Thorne, KA
  • Thorne, KS
  • Thrane, E
  • Tiwari, V
  • Tokmakov, KV
  • Tomlinson, C
  • Toncelli, A
  • Tonelli, M
  • Torre, O
  • Torres, CV
  • Torrie, CI
  • Travasso, F
  • Traylor, G
  • Tse, M
  • Ugolini, D
  • Unnikrishnan, CS
  • Vahlbruch, H
  • Vajente, G
  • Vallisneri, M
  • van den Brand, JFJ
  • Van den Broeck, C
  • van der Putten, S
  • van der Sluys, MV
  • van Heijningen, J
  • van Veggel, AA
  • Vass, S
  • Vasuth, M
  • Vaulin, R
  • Vecchio, A
  • Vedovato, G
  • Veitch, J
  • Veitch, PJ
  • Venkateswara, K
  • Verkindt, D
  • Verma, S
  • Vetrano, F
  • Vicere, A
  • Vincent-Finley, R
  • Vinet, J-Y
  • Vitale, S
  • Vlcek, B
  • Vo, T
  • Vocca, H
  • Vorvick, C
  • Vousden, WD
  • Vrinceanu, D
  • Vyachanin, SP
  • Wade, A
  • Wade, L
  • Wade, M
  • Waldman, SJ
  • Walker, M
  • Wallace, L
  • Wan, Y
  • Wang, J
  • Wang, M
  • Wang, X
  • Wanner, A
  • Ward, RL
  • Was, M
  • Weaver, B
  • Wei, L-W
  • Weinert, M
  • Weinstein, AJ
  • Weiss, R
  • Welborn, T
  • Wen, L
  • Wessels, P
  • West, M
  • Westphal, T
  • Wette, K
  • Whelan, JT
  • Whitcomb, SE
  • White, DJ
  • Whiting, BF
  • Wibowo, S
  • Wiesner, K
  • Wilkinson, C
  • Williams, L
  • Williams, R
  • Williams, T
  • Willis, JL
  • Willke, B
  • Wimmer, M
  • Winkelmann, L
  • Winkler, W
  • Wipf, CC
  • Wittel, H
  • Woan, G
  • Worden, J
  • Yablon, J
  • Yakushin, I
  • Yamamoto, H
  • Yancey, CC
  • Yang, H
  • Yeaton-Massey, D
  • Yoshida, S
  • Yum, H
  • Yvert, M
  • Zadrozny, A
  • Zanolin, M
  • Zendri, J-P
  • Zhang, F
  • Zhang, L
  • Zhao, C
  • Zhu, H
  • Zhu, XJ
  • Zotov, N
  • Zucker, ME
  • Zweizig, J
  • Akerlof, C
  • Baltay, C
  • Bloom, JS
  • Cao, Y
  • Cenko, SB
  • Cwiek, A
  • Cwiok, M
  • Dhillon, V
  • Fox, DB
  • Gal-Yam, A
  • Kasliwal, MM
  • Klotz, A
  • Laas-Bourez, M
  • Laher, RR
  • Law, NM
  • Majcher, A
  • Malek, K
  • Mankiewicz, L
  • Nawrocki, K
  • Nissanke, S
  • Nugent, PE
  • Ofek, EO
  • Opiela, R
  • Piotrowski, L
  • Poznanski, D
  • Rabinowitz, D
  • Rapoport, S
  • Richards, JW
  • Schmidt, B
  • Siudek, M
  • Sokolowski, M
  • Steele, IA
  • Sullivan, M
  • Zarnecki, AF
  • Zheng, W
  • Collaboration, LIGO Sci
  • Collaboration, Virgo
  • Status

    Publication Date

  • March 2014
  • Has Subject Area

    Keywords

  • binaries: close
  • catalogs
  • gravitational waves
  • stars: neutron
  • surveys
  • Digital Object Identifier (doi)

    Start Page

  • 7
  • End Page

  • 7
  • Volume

  • 211
  • Issue

  • 1