The allosteric inhibition of Insulin-like Growth Factor Receptor 1 Kinase (IGF1RK) is a potential strategy to overcome selectivity barriers in targeting receptor tyrosine kinases. We constructed structural models of a series of 12 indole-butyl-amine derivatives which have been reported as allosteric inhibitors of IGF1RK. We further studied dynamics and interactions of each inhibitor in the allosteric pocket via all-atom explicit-solvent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. We discovered that a bulky carbonyl substitution at the R1 indole ring is structurally unfavorable for inhibitor binding in the IGF1RK allosteric pocket. Moreover, we found that the most potent derivative (termed C11) acquires a distinct conformation, forming an allosteric pocket channel with better shape complementarity and interactions with the receptor. In addition to a hydrogen bonding interaction with V1063, the cyano derivative C11 forms a stable hydrogen bond with M1156, which is responsible for its unique binding conformation in the allosteric pocket. Our findings show that the position of chemical substituents at the R1 indole ring with different pharmacophore features influences molecular interactions and binding conformations of the indole-butyl-amine derivatives, hence dramatically affecting their potencies. Our results provide a structural framework for the design of allosteric inhibitors with improved affinities and specificities against IGF1RK.