Permeable reactive barriers (PRBs) remove nitrogen from groundwater by enhancing microbial denitrification. The PRBs consist of woodchips that provide carbon for denitrifiers, but these woodchips also support other anaerobic microbes, including sulfate-reducing bacteria. Some of these anaerobes have the ability to methylate inorganic mercury present in groundwater. Methylmercury is hazardous to human health, so it is essential to understand whether PRBs promote mercury methylation. We examined microbial communities and geochemistry in fresh water and sulfate-enriched PRB flow-through columns by spiking replicates of both treatments with mercuric chloride. We hypothesized that mercury addition could alter bacterial community composition to favor higher abundances of genera containing known methylating taxa and that the sulfate-rich columns would produce more methylmercury after mercury addition, due mainly to an increase in abundance of sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB). However, methylmercury output at the end of the experiment was not different from output at the beginning, due in part to coupled Hg methylation and demethylation. There was a transient reduction in nitrate removal after mercury addition in the sulfate enriched columns, but nitrate removal returned to initial rates after two weeks, demonstrating resilience of the denitrifying community. Since methylmercury output did not increase and nitrate removal was not permanently affected, PRBs could be a low cost approach to combat eutrophication.